Amish Craftsman Furniture – Market Case Study
Transforming Marketing Strategy for The Amish Craftsman
The Amish Craftsman, a single-location furniture and home décor retailer with $3.2 million in annual revenue, had long struggled to unlock the full potential of its marketing efforts. Despite years of testing various messages, offers, and campaigns, the business owners, Kimberly and Steve Murphy, were left frustrated. They sought a clear direction to better reach and motivate new customers while understanding why sales had stagnated. Was it the economy, or were there deeper challenges in their strategy?
Uncovering Hidden Perceptions
Through a detailed research initiative, Elevate uncovered the root issues. The findings revealed that while consumers appreciated the concept of Amish-made furniture, many held assumptions that led them to dismiss its value. Surprisingly, more than half of participants (53%) were unaware that their preferred furniture styles were Amish-made until informed. This revelation highlighted a gap in the retailer’s ability to connect product perception with consumer desires.
Misaligned Messaging Holds Back Growth
The data also revealed that the brand’s advertising messaging failed to resonate, with a significant portion of awareness stemming from “sleepers” — individuals who recognized the brand but were disengaged. This misalignment called for a reimagined strategy focused on what truly mattered to potential customers: quality craftsmanship, customization options, and practical purchase incentives.
A Data-Driven Solution
Elevate designed a comprehensive, data-driven strategy to address these challenges. The approach involved reshaping digital campaigns, including targeted Google and Meta ads, and introducing creative storytelling techniques. Instead of relying on generic showroom visuals, new video campaigns emphasized the emotional experience of owning Amish-crafted furniture—families living their lives, creating memories, and showcasing the timeless quality of these pieces.
Streamlining the Customer Journey
Additionally, Elevate streamlined the customer journey by integrating various touchpoints. From TV commercials to social media ads and the company’s website, each channel worked seamlessly to guide customers toward in-store visits. Incentives like 0% interest and free delivery further encouraged action, aligning perfectly with customer preferences.
Record-Breaking Results
The impact was immediate and remarkable. During a Labor Day sale, The Amish Craftsman achieved a record-breaking $200,000 in revenue over a single weekend and celebrated the largest monthly revenue in the company’s history. Store foot traffic tripled, and many customers who came in for in-stock deals ultimately chose custom-made furniture, demonstrating the effectiveness of the strategy.
Contact us today to learn how Elevates market research expertise can drive your brand’s growth and market share.
